I'm hoping someone can help point me in the right direction on my situation regarding volunteer experiences:
I currently volunteer at the Ronald McDonald House near Children's Memorial Hospital in Chicago checking families in/out of the house, giving tours, and helping with fundraising efforts on a biweekly basis (last 2 years). I also have volunteered for the Glass Slipper Project for the last 8 years.
However, my primary volunteer activity- the one I've poured my heart and soul into- is serving as the recruitment adviser of another chapter of my collegiate sorority. In one year of service thus far, I've managed to completely revamp their intake program, and have the statistical results to back it up (it is purely a numbers game after all). I also won an award at our Regional Conference this year for my efforts in improving this particular college's recruitment process. This experience highlights my organizational, mentorship, teamwork, and problem solving skills.
As my application "story" is centered around my passion for using creative problem solving techniques to implement new processes and foster change throughout the workplace and my community, I can definitely highlight this sorority consulting experience. However, my fear is that admissions committees will view this activity as a continuation of my college years and perhaps signal immaturity. I can also choose to play up the other two activities I've described, but my level of involvement is nowhere near as deep as the recruitment consultant experience.
Other background FYI: Caucasian female; 25 years old; attended Northwestern for undergrad- earning a 3.5 GPA; GMAT 660 (44Q, 37V); works for AdAge's "Agency of the Decade" in the media/marketing/brand management field.