by StaceyKoprince Sun Sep 29, 2013 6:12 pm
Note to others: the sentence he quotes is from my article, which is why I'm answering. Please don't post questions about actual grammar here!
Those sentences do not use possessive pronouns. Those contractions are hiding verbs.
She's thought = she has thought
the pronoun is a subject pronoun and the verb is has thought
She's actually practiced = she has actually practiced
same thing
Finally, even if I had used a possessive to refer to the noun "decision maker," that would have been perfectly correct. Many people misinterpret the rule to think any possessive pronoun should refer to a possessive noun. That is NOT the rule.
Any pronoun form (subjective, objective, possessive) can refer to a noun in noun form.
Mary took her car to the store. Mary is a noun. Her is a possessive pronoun.
The only restriction is when the "noun" itself is in possessive-noun form, because such a noun is actually functioning as an adjective, not a noun.
Mary's car
In this phrase, Mary's is NOT a noun. It's a possessive noun functioning as an adjective. When this is the case, you need to use a possessive pronoun to refer to the possessive noun.
Mary's car is in her garage.
Mary's is a possessive noun; her is a possessive pronoun. Both are functioning as adjectives in the sentence.
Mary's car was in the garage, but she took it to the store.
This is wrong! She is a subject pronoun but Mary's is a possessive noun. Mary's is functioning as an adjective, but she is functioning as a noun.
If the word you're trying to reference (the antecedent) is a noun, then ANY pronoun form is allowed, functioning as a noun or an adjective.
If the word you're trying to reference (the antecedent) is a noun being used as an adjective (a possessive noun), then only a pronoun functioning as an adjective (a possessive pronoun) is allowed.
Stacey Koprince
Instructor
Director, Content & Curriculum
ManhattanPrep